EPA: Water transfers will not need permits Activists criticize move, agency says Clean Water Act will ensure safety

EPA: Water transfers will not need permits
Activists criticize move, agency says Clean Water Act will ensure safety
Take our eco-quizzes
Earth Week - Green Is Universal
So you think you're pretty savvy about environmental issues? See how you compare to others.
And what shade of green are you? Take our color test.

Environment slide shows


'Nature's Best' photos by youth
Click to view some incredible pictures of our wild world that were made by young photographers and published in 'Nature's Best Photography for Kids'.
More from 'Nature's Best'
'Nature's Best' winners
Sea turtle help -- and harvest
Threatened wildlife on 'Red List'
‘Worst Polluted’ sites on Earth
Greenland's melting ice
Border barrier to wildlife
Waterworld — the issues with H2O
Global warming signals

Message board
Share thoughts on green issues, technology
Photo features

More
A villager collects seeds from Giant Water Lilies
EPA

Week in Pictures
As weather challenges the United States, issues of child labor and safe beef fuel protests in Cambodia and South Korea.
Image: Unemployment
AP file

PhotoBlog
View and discuss the pictures and issues that caught our eyes.
Related stories

What’s this?
Senators blast EPA over news of drugs in water
Water levels dropping in North Idaho
More Costs For Boaters
Most popular
• Most viewed • Top rated • Most e-mailed
NBC’s Tim Russert dies of heart attack at 58
Top 10 best places to live in the U.S.
Manson follower Atkins may go free
Major earthquake shakes northern Japan
Iowa river swamps 400 blocks in Cedar Rapids
Most viewed on msnbc.com
Scientists: 115-year-old's brain worked perfectly
Lions at Kenyan park being wiped out
In chilling detail, NYC student recounts torture
2 girls found shot dead in Oklahoma town
Graduating high school at 90: ‘Just plain wonderful’
Most viewed on msnbc.com
NBC’s Tim Russert dies of heart attack at 58
The Education of Ms. Groves
1780 British warship found in Lake Ontario
Manson follower Atkins may go free
No contest plea in case of woman stuck to toilet
Most viewed on msnbc.com
updated 3:31 p.m. ET June 10, 2008

WASHINGTON - The movement of billions of gallons of water around the country for drinking, irrigation and other uses will not require permits under the Clean Water Act, even though the water could contain contaminants, the Bush administration announced Monday.

The new rule will allow water to be diverted from one body to another without a discharge permit, which is typically required when pollutants are released directly into streams, rivers and other surface waters.

Instead, Environmental Protection Agency officials said, the agency will focus on preventing contaminants from entering water sources in the first place. In addition, safe drinking water laws ensure water is clean before it flows into households, and other parts of the Clean Water Act — such as water quality standards — will still protect supplies.
Story continues below ↓advertisement

"Clean water permits should focus on water pollution, not water movement," Benjamin H. Grumbles, the EPA's assistant administrator for water, said in a statement. He later noted that the decision reaffirmed the agency's 30-year view of the Clean Water Act.

Environmental groups criticized the decision, saying it continues to allow pollution to flow into the nation's waterways.

"You could take a really scuzzy canal system ... and pump it into a drinking water supply," said David Guest, managing director of the Florida office for Earthjustice. In 2006, in response to a lawsuit filed by the group, a federal judge directed the South Florida Water Management District to obtain a discharge permit to pump tainted water from drainage canals into Lake Okeechobee.

The EPA's decision Monday comes down on the other side of the issue, and could affect pending court cases, including the appeal in the South Florida case, said James Nutt, the lead counsel for the water management district.

Thousands of water transfers occur across the country each year. They provide water for city dwellers, irrigation projects, dams and ecological restoration. The EPA has never routinely required them to be permitted under the Clean Water Act.

Municipal water districts that rely on water transfers applauded the decision.

"The problem isn't the transfer, it's the introduction of the pollutant in the first place," said Chips Barry, the general manager of the Denver Water Department. Denver receives 45 percent to 55 percent of its drinking water through two tunnels that bore through the Rocky Mountains, releasing the water into the South Platte River before it is piped to the city. "In some cases, the imported water is cleaner than the water in stream in the first place."